part in THE RETURN TO GOLD 187
enjoyed a gold standard throughout, hassuffered as severely as many other countries,that in the United Kingdom the instability ofgold has been a larger factor than the instabilityof the exchange, that the same is true even ofFrance, and that in Italy it has been nearlyas large. On the other hand, in India , whichhas suffered violent exchange fluctuations, thestandard of value has been more stable than inany other country.
We should not, therefore, by fixing the ex-changes get rid of our currency troubles. Itis even possible that this step might weakenour control. The problem of stabilisation hasseveral sides, which we must consider one byone:
1. Devaluation versus Deflation. Do wewish to fix the standard of value, whether ornot it be gold, near the existing value? Or dowe wish to restore it to the pre-war value?
1. Stability of Prices versus Stability of Ex-change. Is it more important that the value ofa national currency should be stable in terms ofpurchasing power, or stable in terms of thecurrency of certain foreign countries?
3. The Restoration of a Gold Standard. Inthe light of our answers to the first two ques-tions, is a gold standard, however imperfect intheory, the best available method for attainingour ends in practice?